What’s wrong?
What is a blog for? I begin this one in the aftermath of a very nasty scandal, in which, it will be remembered, one Damian McBride, a close friend and adviser of the Prime Minister, was revealed to have been plotting with another New Labour luminary to set up a new blog, for the purpose of spreading revolting lies about political rivals and and their families. I don’t want, here or at any time, to adopt a party political stance in this blog: I say nothing about the politics of this scandal . What it vividly demonstrates, though, is the freedom of the blogger to say what he likes, to present as fact any fevered invention of his own, without any need to substantiate it. Print journalists, these days, have a low reputation for accuracy and reliability. All the same, when I was earning my living by journalism in such papers as the Daily Telegraph or the Sunday Times my editors, whenever in an article I presented some new and possibly controversial information not generally known, would always want to know if I could ‘stand up’ my facts. A blogger is under no such restraint, unless it is self-imposed.
So I have given this blog the general title ‘What’s Wrong with the World?’ to remind me of the unseen presence of the greatest journalist of his, and probably any, generation and also to pose a general question: ‘what would Chesterton have said about the times we are living in’? He has never seemed more relevant; I hope over the next few months and years that with your help this blog will explore that relevance. Please contribute to the debate by adding your own comments. (If you don’t want them published here, write to contactus@gkchesterton.org.uk).
To start the debate: I am reminded, in the general context of the credit crunch and the behaviour of some of our bankers, of something Chesterton wrote (in the Autobiography) about his father’s generation, which was, he said ‘dangerously deaf and blind upon the… question of economic exploitation; but it was relatively more vigilant and sensitive upon the … question of financial decency. It never occurred to these people that anybody could possibly admire a man for being what we call “daring” in speculation, any more than a woman for being what we call “daring” in dress.’
Does that remind you of any knighted banker you may have heard of?
–William Oddie
To comment, click on to ‘[No] Comments’
May 19th, 2009 at 9:03 pm
This is wonderful - but no one has commented yet - nor even quoted Chesterton. So I will:
“The whole modern world is pining for a genuinely sensational journalism. This has been discovered by that very able and honest journalist, Mr. Blatchford, who started his campaign against Christianity, warned on all sides, I believe, that it would ruin his paper, but who continued from an honourable sense of intellectual responsibility. He discovered, however, that while he had undoubtedly shocked his readers, he had also greatly advanced his newspaper. It was bought - first, by all the people who agreed with him and wanted to read it; and secondly, by all the people who disagreed with him, and wanted to write him letters. Those letters were voluminous (I helped, I am glad to say, to swell their volume), and they were generally inserted with a generous fulness. Thus was accidentally discovered (like the steam-engine) the great journalistic maxim - that if an editor can only make people angry enough, they will write half his newspaper for him for nothing.”
[GKC Heretics CW1:99-100]
I wish you all the best from the western side of the Water…
Paradoxically yours,
Dr. Thursday
PS: I must point out that your blogg-machinery does not have a “preview” button; perhaps your version presumes a perfection I have not yet attained. I could quote a hilarious essay about that… (”The Real Journalist” in A Miscellany of Men) but I won’t.
PPS as a Chestertonian, I invariably refer to these things as bloggs - I think you will understand why.
June 5th, 2009 at 10:28 pm
Fascinating - thank you Mr Oddie.
August 22nd, 2009 at 8:36 pm
I am not an academic. I just love G.K’s writings, so I intend to give a brief lecture to a small group and hope to promote a discussion of distributism, humour and journalism. My favourite is,”The Flying Inn”.
August 22nd, 2009 at 8:39 pm
I intend to give a short lecture on G.K’s writings and to stimulate a discussion. I am 85, and a retired historian.
May 3rd, 2010 at 5:10 pm
мда , можно зделать маленький сборник…
……
July 5th, 2010 at 5:55 pm
Buy:Zyban.Prevacid.Mega Hoodia.Petcam (Metacam) Oral Suspension.Arimidex.Nexium.Actos.100% Pure Okinawan Coral Calcium.Valtrex.Zovirax.Prednisolone.Retin-A.Human Growth Hormone.Lumigan.Accutane.Synthroid….
August 30th, 2010 at 8:59 am
global http://zscrolloxinr9s.04FORDPARTS.US/tag/mobile+industry+global+Phones/ : mobile…
Phones…